Retro Reviews - September 2025!

Once again, my retro reviews are dominated by my next Top 5 article, and with 2000 coming up, I had plenty of albums to consider.  However, in the end, I decided to review these five, as they are mostly continuations of bands I've been reviewing over the years, which means more power metal!  Instead of breaking these up, I've decided to throw them together, so settle in for a long article!

Helloween - The Dark Ride

After enjoying their latest releases, I figured it was time to try and fill in some of the gaps I had with this band's discography.  I've mentioned before that I've listened up through Better than Raw, and most of it is great power metal.  With this one, the band had retroactively mentioned there was more executive meddling this time, and they went with a bit of a darker, gritter tone.

Things start off with some pretty typical power metal, as tracks like "Mr. Torture," and "All Over the Nations" would have fit in well with any other Helloween album.  Then we get "Escalation 666" and "Mirror Mirror" with both have a much darker tone and mid-tempo chugging, and their lead single "If I Could Fly" feels almost like an alternative rock song.  The rest of the album bounces bounces around these two styles.  While the power metal tracks are classic in style, they do feel a bit less inspired than usual, while the slower, grittier tracks are a mixed bag, but feature some neat ideas.  However, to the band's credit, the album never feels uneven or jarring, the different sounds making the album feel kind of diverse.

Personally, I find the later material on the album to be stronger.  "Mirror Mirror" is an interesting take on the classic fairy tale, then "The Departed (Sun Is Going Down)" and "I Live For Your Pain" are the best of the slower, grittier songs.  Meanwhile, "We Damn the Night" is the best of the power metal side, the epic closing title track features all of this and more.  While this isn't the band at their best, they've certainly had worse, and I think there's plenty to like here, making this more like a dark horse than a black sheep.

AC/DC - Stiff Upper Lip

After Ballbreaker, these Aussies seemed to settle into a pattern of putting out an album every 5-8 years, as I'm sure their live show was the more profitable side of their band.  As for this album, they definitely drawn upon the blues rock that dominated their sound in the 70s, making this feel like something of a throw back.

Of course, this is a minor shift, as the band's sound is one of the most unchanging things in the history of rock music, and that's just fine.  Things start of well with the rockin' title track, "Meltdown" and "House of Jazz" have the strongest blues elements on the album, and "Hold Me Back" has this near minimal approach before it builds to its anthemic end.  "Safe in New York City" has some interesting energy, and the blues come back for "Satellite Blues" and "Come and Get It."  I do think the album does lose some steam towards the end, but "Give It Up" is a solid closer.  Overall, it's another AC/DC album, designed to get your headbanging from beginning to end.  I will say, though, that I think this one was better than Ballbreaker, and probably on the upper end of their discography.

For what it's worth, this was the last album I needed to hear to complete my listening of their entire studio discography.  It took many years (long before I started the blog), but I can say with confidence that they've been largely consistent over their entire history. I might at some point create a Retrospective Article, filling in the reviews I need to, but that will probably have to wait until next year sometime.  In the meantime, they remain the band we've always enjoyed, and this album is a good example why.

Rhapsody of Fire - Dawn of Victory

This year was definitely one for power metal, with this one being the third in their Emerald Sword Saga.  In the last album, our hero made it to the tower to find the titular weapon and is now on his way back to face the evil that threatens the land.  Naturally, this means another set of bombastic, high speed power metal!

Musically, nothing has changed at all from the last album.  We get more neo-classical orchestrations to go with all of Luca Turilli's shredding guitars, and Fabio Lione does his best to share the story in his soaring voice.  As for that story, the hero brings the armies together into an alliance against the evil Akron, but when his friend's lover (a princess) gets kidnapped, the vile lord wants the Emerald Sword for himself.  The heroes try to anticipate a trap only to get captured, and the sword falls into the hands of evil, and our main hero is the only one to escape with his life.  I bring up the story here, as the album starts rather triumphant, but the songs get darker and more desperate as it goes (at least for power metal, anyway).  Of course, there are still some strange breaks, like "The Village of the Dwarves" with its folky respite, but most of the time, it's pretty melodramatic theatrics, which the music holds together well enough.

This is one of those albums where the great songs are great, but the rest is pretty forgettable.  I liked the title track and "Holy Thunderforce," as they feature some pretty epic melodies and symphonics, and the massive closer "The Mighty Ride of the Firelord" has a little of everything.  However, the rest of the songs, while not necessarily bad (though "The Bloody Rage of the Titans" was another strange one), they aren't as memorable as those three.  In any case, the band is once again spot on with their orchestrations and arrangements, and certainly sell their operatic pretentions pretty well. 

Iron Maiden - Brave New World

After enduring the two Blaze Bayley albums, it was high time I got back into this band and their reunion with Bruce Dickinson and Adrian Smith.  However, they decide to hang on to Janick Gers, making the first album with three guitarists.  In fact, this lineup has remained ever since!  In any case, this album is pretty much a return to form for the band, calling upon their 80s majesty.

I know I haven't reviewed any Dickinson album before now, so let's get the obvious out of the way: this man is a great vocalist and frontman.  He's one of the greats for good reason, and he sounds great here.  The rest of the band is definitely back to normal after stumbling through the 90s.  The rhythms and hooks are tight again, and the guitar work is exemplary as always.  Essentially, it's Maiden doing what they do best, which is writing solid, melodic heavy metal, and after the last two albums, it's nearly a relief to hear the crew still have it where it matters.  The long songs have return as well, as the band leans more into their proggy side like "Rime of the Ancient Mariner" or "Alexander the Great."

Listening to this album is like putting on an old pair of comfortable shoes.  While long-time Maiden fans will already know how good songs like "The Wicker Man" and "Blood Brothers" are, but I also rather liked "Ghost of the Navigator" and "The Fallen Angel."  There are no surprises and you know what to expect, but at the same time, you can't help but feel good about it anyway, simply because it's executed well.  As a consequence, the album might not stand up well against their classics, but it makes for a solid return to form, and a new baseline for what follows.

Gamma Ray - Blast from the Past

Just to round things out, I decided to throw this collection on and give it a listen.  Technically, it's a compilation for the band, but a majority of it was recorded, letting the fans pick the songs on their website.  While the songs themselves weren't changed much, there are a few major differences that make this more than just a typical Greatest Hits album.

First is the production, making the re-recorded versions feel more rich and layered, so they feel more in-line with what the band had been doing at the time.  It also gives them a welcome extra punch of power metal.  The other major difference is that the vocals of Ralf Scheepers (now happily working in Primal Fear at this point) were now provided by Kai Hansen.  While some of the re-recorded songs were clearly written with Ralf's hefty vocals in mind, but Kai does well enough, especially on the faster songs that call for his soaring style.  Overall, I don't know if this is a particularly vital release, but definitely shows how Gamma Ray has finally established their style.  Enjoyable, but probably not vital outside of diehard fans.

New Releases - September 2025!

After spending so much time on older albums, I figured I should shake things up with some new releases.  This is looking to be another great year for power metal, as not only do we have some of the big names putting out some great albums, but I've got a new band that has it where it matters as well.  Figuring out my Top 5 for the year is going to be tough!

Primal Fear - Domination

When I reviewed their last two albums, I find them to be a little underwhelming compared to earlier releases.  (Though, when I relistened to them recently, I decided Metal Commando was the better album after all.)  Now with new members Thalìa Bellazecca and André Hilgers on guitars and drums respectively, they carry on with their iconic heavy/power metal sound.

Not that I was expecting any kind of major change, of course.  This band really is pretty consistent.  However, I do think this album has stronger melodies and more of an uplifting tone, tapping into a bit more of a Helloween style than usual.  This is very noticeable on their first few tracks, with "Destroyer" and "Far Away" really pushing into a very classic power metal sound.  Things get grittier in a more typical style with songs like "The Hunter," "I Am the Primal Fear," and the weirdly intense "March Boy March."  There's also a few elements of AOR, especially with songs like "Tears of Fire," the instrumental "Hallucinations," "Crossfire," and the seven-minute epic "Eden."  Hearing these makes me think that Magnus Karlsson had a bigger hand in the song-writing this time around, as I'm hearing similar things as the work that he's done with Frontiers Records.  Naturally, the rest of the band hammers out their parts well, with Ralf Scheeper's voice roaring and soaring over everything, getting in some pretty good wails.  Overall, it feels like the band has really gotten their energy and power back.

The main concern I have with it is that the album might be a little too long.  While none of these songs are bad, per se, there are a few that felt like filler, or at least not as strong, such as "Heroes and Gods," and "Scream."  However, these are nitpicks on what is definitely a solid album, probably their best since Apocalypse, and certainly a contender for Top 5 of the year!

Helloween - Giants and Monsters

Speaking of Helloween, these power metal legends finally released a follow up to their great self-titled album from 2021.  When I reviewed that one, I loved it, even if it was a little clunky here and there, and it eventually ended up in my Top 5 for that year at #2!  Now, four years later, the band is still rocking the three vocalists, and we get another great set of power metal tunes!

Naturally, all the staples are here: plenty of noodly riffs and solos, high energy rhythms, and wailing vocals.  If there is one thing that kept coming to mind this time is how much they sound like Gamma Ray.  I know that may seem kind of redundant, as Kai Hansen always has his sound, regardless of what band he's in, but something about these songs have that Queen-like emphasis that Kai likes to use on his Gamma Ray material.  (And it turns out that "Majestic" was a left over Gamma Ray song from 20 years ago that Kai rediscovered when helping to write this album.)  Maybe this is just semantics, but I did notice it multiple times.

Still, there's some great power metal, not that would be a shock, really, as these guys have been doing it well since the 80s.  Thinks start off great with the high-speed tracks "Giants on the Run" and "Savior of the World," but they also get epic with the two eight-minute songs, "Universe (Gravity For Hearts)" and "Majestic."  They do drift into AOR territory with tracks like "A Little Is a Little Too Much," "This Is Tokyo," and "Hand of God," which aren't bad but do bring the energy down a little.  "Under the Moonlight" is probably the weakest track, as it did sound a little strange compared to everything else.  However, what does work here holds the album up well.  I don't know if this is better than their last album (as that was quite good), but this is also a Top 5 album for 2025.  I'm sure I'll have some real trouble deciding between this and Primal Fear's work when it comes to placement!

Dragonknight - Legion

So after listening to two legends of the genre, here's a completely new power metal band from Finland.  While they may not be doing anything new or original, I can't deny that the execution of their work is pretty solid.

For fans of symphonic power metal, there's a lot that's familiar here, with Twilight Force being the most prominent comparison, though fans of Dragonland and Rhapsody of Fire will find plenty to like.  It's hard to know who is responsible for what, as the band relies on stage names, but Metal Archives at least tells me the singer is Mikael Salo, who apparently has been in a number of other power metal bands, and it shows.  He sings with experience, being very theatrical, but he isn't afraid to get a little gritty when it's needed.  While I don't think this is a concept album, it could definitely be interpreted as one, as it flows from song to song pretty well.  The orchestrations are bombastic and well arranged, and the music is tight and powerful, making sure each piece leaves an impact.

It would be very easy to dismiss this band as "more of the same," and I do fear this band might get lost in the cracks, but I can't deny they have something here, as I liked most of the songs.  The ending tracks do get a little weird (especially with the 12/8 rhythm they try on "The Revelation"), but I enjoyed "The Legions of Immortal Dragonlords," "Defender of Dragons," and "Storm Bringer" for having some good energy and epic arrangements, and I rather liked the ballad "Astarte Rise," as it had a strong story that built with the music very well.  Overall, it might not be unique, but there is something to be said for doing things well, and this group might be one to keep an eye on in the future.

Top 5 of 1995!!

Still making progress on these articles, but it's gonna be tight if I want to get through all of them before the end of the year.  As for this one, 1995 was definitely a curious time, as genres were evolving and expanding.  As usual, I should explain that I can't listen to everything, and these lists are pretty subjective to me.  However, after listening to a bunch of albums (including ones I didn't review), I felt these were the five that stood out the most.

5. The Flower Kings - Back in the World of Adventures

I'll admit that third-wave prog rock can be a mixed bag sometimes, as I feel they tend to lean a little too much into jazz fusion for my tastes.  However, Roine Stolt and his buddies really went big for their (kinda) debut album, really capturing the whimsy and mystery of those classic 70s styles.  It's not perfect, but it does establish some decent atmosphere with slick passages and melodies throughout.

4. Paragon - World of Sin

After reviewing it last week, I did wonder if this might not sneak into the Top 5 somewhere.  Compared to the other two I reviewed, this one felt the most complete and consistent, with their wearing their Metal Church influences on their sleeves for their brand of power metal.  While they haven't quite reached their full potential (and the great vocalist Andreas Babuschkin hadn't shown up yet), it's a debut that certainly demands attention.

3. Blind Guardian - Imaginations from the Other Side

At this point, Blind Guardian is firing on all cylinders, nailing their peculiar mix of power, folk, and speed metal.  The title track, "Bright Eyes," and "I'm Alive" are highlights for me, and I know this album has plenty of acclaim in the power metal fandom.  It's only below the others as I think they're stronger and have more of the power metal style I prefer, but that I still think this is a great album in the genre.

2. Gamma Ray - Land of the Free

Losing Ralf Scheepers may seem like a big deal, but Kai Hansen really steps up to the mic and discovers that he has a good voice for this concept album about freedom and oppression.  It's also when the band really embraces their power metal sound, helping to establish the genre along with their contemporaries.  The album does get a little clunky here and there, but honestly, these are nit-picks, and certainly not enough to prevent it from getting such a high placing.

1. Stratovarius - Fourth Dimension

While they wouldn't have their iconic lineup just yet, it can't be denied that Stratovarius really starts with this album.  I love "Against the Wind," "Distant Skies," and "We Hold the Key," and the rest of the album isn't too shabby.  Timo Kotipelto's soaring vocals and Timo Tolkki's neo-classical guitars really come together to make some solid stuff, and the first of a string of excellent power metal albums!